Roller Liner Tusch - Benefit Eyeliner

My go to eyeliner

This eyeliner stays on all day and is the easiest to apply. Love this product.

this eyeliner sucks

i bought two of these, and they both dried out so quickly

Love Brown

Please don't discontinue this is the only eye liner I've used for years now. The brown is my favorite and like that it's matte.

Favorite

Sad they don't sell this in beauty stores but now come to the site to buy. Best color brown, stays all day and doesn't bother my sensitive eyes.

My holy grail eyeliner

Been using this bad boy for years I will never change any time I use other brands it's either too shine of a finish or too dry it cracks but this one is my favorite forever

IT DOESN'T MOVE

Best smudge proof/budge proof liner. You can literally do a thick graphic liner look with no primer and that look isn't moving. I applied this liner in the morning and went to bikram yoga in the evening and it lasted through a 90 minute yoga session in a 105 degree room and didn't budge. Here's a photo for proof. Yasss benefit.

I love this eyeliner

I love that it comes in brown! I got the hang of the felt tip and I realize it is just perfection. I do shake it toward the tip to freshen up the product. Please don't discontinue it's the perfect brown. All others suck.

It is NOT waterproof..............not even a little bit.

I do like the way this eyeliner applies so easily and I like the precision tip; however, the product claims say it's waterproof. My eyes tend to water at times due to allergies and as soon as any moisture gets near it, it comes right off. There is NOTHING waterproof about this. You don't even need make-up remover to remove it...............just a little bit of water.

Very poor eyeliner

Does not easily apply as advertise. Does not look dark matte as advertised. Very dry and hard to apply!

Bad application

My second time using my liner and it has dried out. On first use it smudged everywhere and only lasted an hour max. Definitely not worth the money.

Loved at first but now disappointed

I LOVED this the first time I tried it. It is such a nice brown color and it applies so easily. However - as soon as this mixes with eyeshadow it turns gold/light brown. It totally changes the color. I even tried different brands of eyeshadow and every brand turned it light brown.

Did not work

I open pen and tried to use but a very little liquid came out