Aqua Resist Color Ink - Eyeliner

It’s great but…

The applicator could be better the felt tip kind of falls apart after a while so it’s hard to get a clean line, but that being said the formula is amazing! It’s one of the only eyeliners that my sensitive eyes can tolerate

It works, but the liner pen is super stiff and I have to continuously go in to get more product to make one line. It looks great once the product is on, but it takes twice as long to do a wing liner.

Why change the formula!?

Too thin formula that bleeds and smudges. The ealier formula was much better. Have used this for more than 10 years and this formula is not the same anymore. Shame.

Go to liner

Love. Reliable eyeliner and pretty easy to use. Shake the bottle for more ink kinda like those paint markers. Lasts me more than 8 hours on without any skin prep or setting spray. Will definitely be purchasing again

garbage

Garbage. Separated and applies as a watery streak.

Good quality liner, even after time

This liner performs as well as the greats. 10/10 would recommend. I use it with a brown pencil to get a less severe look.

Meh. Won't buy again.

Not good! I used this stuff on several occasions trying to get it to work. The lines were good and easy to do. Pigment was questionable because it would try to streak, and adding more did not really fix it. I usually filled it in with a liner pen once it dried down. And every time I used this, my eyelashes would get uncomfortably dry afterward. Not sure why. It could have transferred on to my lashes since it is quite watery, and taking this off at the end of the day with a balm or an oil always stings my eyes. There are better options out there for sure, so it's a no for me. Would not buy again.

Striking Chameleon is truly striking!

I'm glad I bought the shade striking chameleon even though it has some bad reviews. It could be because I have very fair skin, so it shows up on me and the blue violet combo is gorgeous!

Big disappointment

I was very excited to see a plum liquid liner. I use liquid liner every day and as someone with green eyes, this was just the colour I was looking for. Unfortunately the product sucks. No matter how much I shook it, every time I applied it, it was streaky. If I wanted any colour payoff, I’d have to apply multiple coats which didn’t work, the bottom layers would start to come up and off. Really disappointed with this product, especially at this price point. Will not be repurchasing, and hope that my favourite drugstore mainstays expand their colour range.

Separated formula

The formula is easy to separate out and it really need a good shake to mix it up. The color is great, and easy to draw. However I don’t think that I will buying it again.

Not for me

Threw it away. Dry and cakey. Did not glide on smoothly.

Disappointing - too dry/ not intense enough color

Applicator is dry before I finish one lid. The color was not nearly as intense as I'd hoped. I had to dip in the tube at least twice and go over each eyelid twice to get the effect I wanted. It looks great once on but it did transfer onto my upper lid more than I would want and it's a cool day - I'd hate to see what it does in the summer. My search for a replacement to Bobbi Brown's discontinued liquid liner continues.