They're Real! Liner Xtreme Precision - Benefit Eyeliner

Awesome for wings!

This is a fantastic liner! The tip is nice and precise for sharp lines, and the black is dark! It's nice and juicy, not on the dryer side like some liners. It lasts all day for me and comes off easily with my normal cleanser and water, no need for makeup remover. Love the red packaging too!

Good liner.

Like this eyeliner but would like it in purple because i used to buy they're real push up liner and it was sadly discontinued.

Eh.

Not exactly impressed with this eyeliner. The lines it makes are sharp but not super pigmented you have to go over it quite a few times for it to be dark enough to look good. It's expensive and I would not buy this again. Kind of a waste of money since it doesn't perform as well as I expected.

Awesome liquid liner!

This pen is super precise and the ink is super black. It has lasted me for a few months so far and I love it. The pen has a super thin and flexible tip which lets me do whatever shape I want.

Pretty Good

I've tried a lot of makeup brands and eyeliners. I like this brand and I wanted to love this one and it is good but it's not my favorite. I feel like it didn't last as long as some other brands I get. It goes on nicely if you like felt tip. I've changed back to a brush and liquid after this one dried out actually. I personally can't afford to buy one of these every two months but I'd you like this brand and type of applicator you may like it.

Very nice eyeliner

I love this eyeliner! The pigmentation is deep black, you don't need multiple coats. The eyeliner glides smoothly and with precision. If you mess up, it is easy to remove. I don't like the packaging because it looks cheap, but the product itself is so good quality I'm giving this full stars.

Don't miss out on this eyeliner!

I was hesitant at first about trying this eyeliner because of the name and the cheap red packaging. However, I am glad that I finally decided to give it a try because the performance blew me away! The tip smoothly glided over my eyelids and I was able to create clean looking cat eyes in no time. When I messed up a little, it was easy to remove and redo my cat eye. The pigmentation is rich black. I think this eyeliner by Benefit is as perfect as Lancôme's Idole eyeliner.

Used once and doesn't work at all now.

I have tried to reach out for a refund, with no luck. this product does not work. It was dry when I got it. Save your money.

Great product except for the brush, where the hairs splay

The liner stays beautifully in place, doesn't flake or smudge, but brush hairs splay outwards soon after the first few applications, making it hard to apply because the splayed out hairs get in the way. Please change/improve the brush tip so it stays straight and the product would be perfect!

Smooth lines

It gives extremely smooth lines, you could even draw with it if you wanted too. It wears pretty well throughout the day with no smudges. Remember to shake well before use or it won't glide

Not pigmented & dries up

Eyeliner goes on wonderfully at first. I'm 49 so I wanted to find one that was easy to apply and didn't drag across as with aging eyes these are hard to find. I bought this in the brown and was very excited to try it as I normally use black. I was very pleased with the application part as it lines perfectly without much effort. However, I was disappointed in the fact that its not very pigmented so once it dries you aren't able to see the product well. Also, after a couple of uses the product no longer applies easy and has somewhat dried up. As another review stated, I also shook it and left it upside down overnight and this didn't make any difference.

Disappears

Goes on looks great for half an hour and then disappears . Definitely not waterproof, smudgy. Awful product. Wish I hadn't wasted my money.